Payroll services handle the calculation, distribution, and reporting of employee wages, ensuring businesses pay their staff accurately and on time. Whether managed in-house or outsourced, these services streamline payroll processing, handle tax filings, and ensure compliance with labor laws.

‍

In fact, up to 40% of small businesses incur payroll-related fines due to compliance errors each year.

‍

Businesses risk overspending on unnecessary features or facing unexpected processing fees if there are no clear payroll pricing structures. Every expense (such as software subscriptions and payroll outsourcing) affects profitability. Hence, it’s important to choose a cost-effective solution.

‍

This article breaks down the question, “How much do payroll services cost?” including insights to help startups and small businesses make informed decisions that optimize cash flow and streamline payroll operations.

‍

How Much Do Payroll Services Cost?

‍

When managing payrolls, it’s important to understand the associated costs irrespective of the size of your business. This helps you understand the financial implications of in-house management and outsourcing to payroll service providers.

Estimated Payroll Costs by Business Size

Small Businesses (up to 25 employees)

For small businesses, payroll services usually range from $175 to $300 per month. This estimate is based on a common pricing structure that includes a base fee of around $50, plus an additional $5 per employee.

Medium-Sized Businesses (approximately 100 employees)

Mid-sized companies can expect monthly payroll costs between $550 and $1,100. This calculation follows the same pricing model, with the base fee plus per-employee charges accumulating as the workforce grows.

‍

Large Enterprises (around 500 employees)

For larger organizations, payroll expenses can increase to between $2,500 and $3,000+ per month. While some providers may offer discounted per-employee rates for high headcounts, the overall costs remain substantial due to the volume of transactions.

‍

In-House Payroll Management vs. Outsourcing

Managing payroll internally involves several expenses, including:

• Staffing Costs: Employing a payroll administrator can cost between $20,000 to $45,000 annually, excluding benefits and taxes.
• Software Investments: Payroll software licenses range from $20 to $200 per month, depending on features and capabilities.
• Training and Compliance: Continuous education is necessary to stay updated on tax laws and regulations, incurring additional costs and time commitments.

‍

While in-house management offers direct control, it requires significant resources and carries the risk of costly errors due to compliance complexities.

‍

On the other hand, outsourcing shifts payroll responsibilities to specialized providers, comprising tasks like wage calculation, tax filing, and compliance management. Costs usually include:

• Service Fees: Ranging from $20 to $150 per employee per month, varying based on services included.
• Setup Fees: One-time charges between $50 and $200 for initial system configuration.
• Additional Services: Optional features like benefits administration or HR support may incur extra charges.

‍

Outsourcing can be cost-effective, especially for small to medium-sized businesses, by reducing the likelihood of errors and freeing internal resources. Studies have shown that businesses outsourcing payroll spend approximately 27% less than those managing it in-house.

‍

How Payroll Pricing is Structured

Payroll service providers offer different structures to accommodate different business needs. Highlighted below are the pricing models to help you determine the most cost-effective option for your organization.

‍

Per Employee Per Month (PEPM)

The PEPM model charges a fixed monthly fee for each active employee, regardless of the number of payroll runs. This structure is beneficial for larger businesses that process frequent payrolls, such as weekly payments, or those with complex payroll requirements, including multiple tax jurisdictions or numerous garnishments.

‍

Examples of providers using PEPM include:

• Gusto: Charges a base fee plus a per-employee monthly rate, providing comprehensive payroll and HR tools.
• OnPay: Offers a similar structure with a monthly base fee and an additional per-employee charge.

‍

Typical fees associated with PEPM can range from $2 to $15 per employee per month, depending on the services included.

Per Payroll Run (Per Frequency)

In the per-payroll-run model, businesses incur charges each time they process payroll. This structure can be more cost-effective for companies with less frequent payroll schedules, such as bi-weekly or monthly payments.

‍

In this model, there is a base Fee (i.e., a fixed fee per payroll run). Also, there is a per-employee charge (an additional fee for each employee included in the payroll).

‍

Here’s how the per-payroll-run model impacts weekly and monthly payrolls:

• Weekly Payrolls: This may lead to higher cumulative costs due to the increased number of payroll runs.
• Monthly Payrolls: Fewer runs can result in lower overall expenses.

‍

Small businesses may find this model more economical due to limited employees and infrequent payroll runs. Large enterprises, on the other hand, could incur higher costs with this model due to the frequency and volume of payroll processing.

‍

Software Fees

Payroll software costs can vary based on licensing, subscription models, and potential hidden fees. This model comprises:

• Licensing Fees: One-time or recurring charges for using the software.
• Subscription Fees: Ongoing costs, often monthly or annually, for access to cloud-based services.
• Hidden Fees: Additional charges for setup, support, or extra features.

‍

Here’s how this model impacts cloud-based and on-premises systems:

• Cloud-Based: It involves subscription fees and offers scalability and remote access.
• On-Premises: It may require higher upfront costs for licensing and infrastructure but can offer greater control over data.

‍

Examples of providers using this model and their pricing models include:

• Paychex Flex: Offers tiered packages with a starting price of $39/month plus $5 per employee.
• Zoho Payroll: Provides a comprehensive plan at $19/month plus $3 per employee, with annual billing options available.

‍

Fixed Pricing

Fixed pricing models charge a consistent fee regardless of the number of employees or payroll runs. This approach can be beneficial for businesses seeking predictable expenses and those with stable payroll needs.

The model has a predetermined monthly or annual charge that covers all payroll services. It makes budgeting easy due to consistent costs.

‍

Factors That Affect the Cost of Payroll Services

Understanding the factors that influence the cost of payroll services helps businesses manage their expenses effectively. Let’s take a look at these factors:

‍

Number of Employees

The size of your workforce impacts payroll costs. Many payroll service providers charge a base fee plus a per-employee fee.

‍

For instance, a small business with 25 employees might pay between $6 and $12 per employee each month, in addition to a monthly base fee ranging from $20 to $180. As your team grows, these per-employee charges accumulate, leading to higher expenses.

‍

Seasonal hiring further complicates payroll management. Bringing on temporary staff during peak periods increases payroll processing tasks, potentially raising costs due to the fluctuating number of employees and the need for frequent adjustments.

‍

Payroll Processing Frequency

The frequency of payroll runs—weekly, bi-weekly, semi-monthly, or monthly—affects pricing structures. More frequent payroll processing increases administrative tasks, leading to higher costs.

‍

For example, processing payroll weekly results in 52 payroll runs per year, whereas a monthly schedule totals only 12. Evaluating the balance between meeting employee expectations and managing costs is essential when determining payroll frequency. 

‍

Level of Automation and Features

Investing in payroll software with automation capabilities can streamline processes like direct deposits and tax compliance, potentially reducing manual errors and saving time.

‍

However, advanced features such as benefits management, time tracking, and HR integrations often come with additional costs. Assessing which features align with your business needs helps you select a cost-effective solution without paying for unnecessary extras. 

‍

Compliance and Tax Filing Services

Ensuring compliance with tax regulations is an important component of payroll processing. Many providers offer tax filing services to handle calculations, withholdings, and submissions on your behalf.

‍

While these services add to the cost, they reduce the risk of penalties associated with errors or late filings. Staying updated on tax laws and understanding how they influence service pricing can help with budgeting for these services.

‍

Customization and Add-Ons

Tailoring payroll services to fit specific business requirements often involves additional expenses. Extra charges may apply for benefits administration, employee self-service portals, or integration with existing accounting software.

‍

Deciding between basic payroll outsourcing and comprehensive HR solutions depends on your organization's complexity and resource availability. 

‍

Industry-Specific Considerations

Certain industries, such as construction or healthcare, have unique payroll requirements due to complex labor laws and compliance standards.

‍

These specialized needs can lead to higher payroll processing costs, as providers may need to allocate additional resources to ensure adherence to industry-specific regulations.

‍

You can anticipate and manage these expenses by understanding your industry’s specific needs. 

‍

Tips for Saving Money on Payroll Services

Managing payroll efficiently helps businesses control expenses without compromising on employee satisfaction or compliance. Here are practical strategies to help you reduce payroll costs:

‍

Compare Multiple Payroll Providers

Evaluate various providers, focusing on their pricing structures, features, and customer support. Many providers offer free trials or demo periods, allowing you to assess their services before committing. Using these trials helps ensure the provider meets your business needs without incurring unnecessary expenses.

‍

Choose the Right Pricing Model for Your Business

Payroll services usually offer different pricing models, such as per-employee-per-month (PEPM) or fixed pricing. Startups and small businesses might find PEPM models more cost-effective, as they scale with the number of employees.

‍

Larger companies, on the other hand, may benefit from fixed pricing, which can offer predictable costs regardless of employee count. Conducting a cost-benefit analysis of each model will help determine the most economical choice for your organization.

‍

Use Payroll Software Discounts and Bundles

Many payroll service providers offer discounts when bundling payroll with other services like human resources or accounting software.

‍

In addition, watch out for seasonal promotions or special offers tailored to startups and small businesses. Taking advantage of these discounts can lead to substantial savings over time.

‍

Minimize Extra Fees

Be vigilant about additional fees that can inflate payroll processing costs. These may include charges for setup, tax filing, or premium services that you might not need. Carefully review your service agreement and opt out of unnecessary add-ons to keep expenses in check.

‍

Also, understand the fee structure of your payroll provider for transparency and to ensure accurate budgeting.

‍

Automate Payroll to Reduce Administrative Costs

Automation streamlines processes such as calculating wages, withholding taxes, and distributing paychecks, leading to time and cost efficiencies.

‍

For small businesses, investing in reliable payroll software can offer a high return on investment by simplifying complex tasks and reducing the likelihood of costly mistakes.

‍

Wrapping Up

The cost of payroll services depends on pricing models and factors such as company size, payroll frequency, and required features. This article has explored these factors to help you manage expenses efficiently while staying compliant with regulations.

‍

Assess your business’s specific needs before selecting a payroll service provider. Consider your employee count, payroll complexity, and the level of automation you require. This will help you choose a solution that aligns with your operational demands and budget.

‍

Managing payroll alongside HR, compliance, finance, and equity management can be overwhelming. By handling these administrative tasks, Chore allows you to focus on growing your business. With Chore’s expertise, you can streamline operations, ensure compliance, and optimize payroll efficiency. Learn more.

‍

FAQs

What is the most cost-effective payroll pricing model?

The best pricing model depends on your business size, payroll frequency, and operational needs:

• Per Employee Per Month (PEPM): Ideal for small businesses with a stable workforce. Usually costs between $5 and $15 per employee per month, making it predictable for budgeting.
• Per Payroll Run: Suitable for businesses that process payroll less frequently. If you run payroll bi-weekly or monthly, this model can be cheaper than PEPM, with costs around $25 to $100 per payroll run plus per-employee fees.
• Fixed Pricing: Best for large companies that want predictable costs. A flat monthly rate (e.g., $100 to $500+ per month) covers all payroll processing, making it ideal for businesses with 50+ employees.
• Software-Based Pricing: Cost-effective for businesses that handle payroll in-house. Cloud-based payroll software can start at $20 to $150 per month, with optional add-ons for tax filing and compliance. This is a great option for tech-savvy businesses that want more control over payroll processes.

‍

If you have a small team and only process payroll once a month, per-run pricing may be cheaper. However, if you process payroll frequently, PEPM or software-based pricing might offer better savings in the long run.

‍

What hidden fees should businesses watch out for in payroll services?

Some payroll providers advertise low base prices but include additional fees that can increase your overall costs. Here are some common hidden charges businesses should be aware of:

• Setup and implementation fees: Some providers charge a one-time setup fee to onboard your business. Costs can range from $50 to $200 or more, depending on the complexity of your payroll system.
• Tax filing and compliance support fees: Payroll providers often charge extra for handling payroll tax filings, W-2s, 1099s, and compliance reports. Some services include this in their base pricing, while others charge $5 to $15 per filing.
• Direct deposit processing fees: Some payroll companies charge a per-transaction fee for direct deposits. This can be $1 to $5 per transaction or a flat monthly rate. ACH processing fees may also apply.
• Year-end tax forms (W-2s and 1099s) fees: Many providers charge an additional fee to generate and distribute W-2 and 1099 forms for employees and contractors. The cost per form can range from $2 to $10 per document.
• Additional customer support fees: Some providers offer basic support for free, but charge extra for premium customer service. 24/7 support, dedicated account managers, or faster response times may require an additional monthly fee.
• Payroll corrections and off-cycle payroll runs: If you need to correct an error or run an unscheduled payroll, there may be an additional charge. Fees range from $10 to $50 per off-cycle payroll run.
• Employee self-service portal fees: Some payroll providers charge for enabling employee access to pay stubs, tax documents, and time-tracking tools. This fee can be $2 to $10 per employee per month.
• Integration fees for third-party software: Connecting payroll software to accounting or HR platforms (e.g., QuickBooks, Xero, or HR tools) may incur additional costs. Fees vary but can be $5 to $25 per month per integration.

‍

Is payroll outsourcing cheaper than in-house payroll processing?

The cost-effectiveness of outsourcing vs. in-house payroll depends on your business size and complexity.

‍

Outsourcing is usually more cost-effective for small businesses because it eliminates the need to hire payroll staff and invest in payroll software. It also reduces compliance risks and administrative burdens.

‍

In-house payroll can be more affordable for larger companies if they already have an HR or accounting team that can manage payroll. However, it requires investment in payroll software, compliance training, and ongoing administrative work.

‍

Outsourcing payroll saves time and reduces costly errors for most small to mid-sized businesses, making it a better financial choice.

‍

What are the best payroll service providers for small businesses?

Some popular payroll providers for small businesses include:

• Gusto: Best for startups and growing businesses
• ADP: Great for scalability and HR integration
• QuickBooks Payroll: Ideal for businesses using QuickBooks accounting software
• Paychex: Best for businesses needing full-service payroll and compliance support