Think your unprofitable startup can’t benefit from tax credits? Think again.

‍

The R&D payroll tax offset is useful for early-stage and pre-revenue startups that are not yet profitable. Unlike traditional R&D tax credits, which offset income taxes, this offset allows qualified small businesses to apply the credit toward their payroll tax liability.

‍

As of 2023, startups can claim up to $500,000 per year in R&D tax credits against their Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes. This means you can keep building, hiring, and innovating even without generating revenue.

‍

This R&D tax credit guide will discuss how to take advantage of the payroll tax offset.

‍

What Is the R&D Payroll Tax Offset?

The R&D Payroll Tax Offset is a provision under the U.S. research and development tax credit program that allows eligible startups to apply their R&D tax credits against payroll taxes, rather than income taxes.

‍

This is beneficial for pre-revenue and unprofitable startups that don't yet owe federal income tax but still incur payroll tax liabilities. Traditionally, the R&D tax credit could only be used to offset income tax (meaning early-stage businesses with no profits couldn’t benefit).

‍

But thanks to legislation like the Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes (PATH) Act of 2015 and the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, qualified small businesses (QSBs) can now apply up to $500,000 annually of their startup R&D credits to offset the employer portion of Social Security and Medicare taxes.

‍

The payroll tax offset allows startups to reclaim a portion of their research investment and reinvest it into hiring, product development, or growth initiatives without waiting to become profitable.

‍

Who Qualifies for the R&D Payroll Tax Offset?

To claim the R&D Payroll Tax Offset, your startup must meet the IRS definition of a Qualified Small Business (QSB). This special designation allows early-stage companies (especially those not yet profitable) to apply the R&D tax credit against payroll taxes instead of income taxes.

‍

Here are the two main eligibility criteria:

• Less than $5 million in gross receipts for the tax year you're claiming the credit.
• No gross receipts more than five years before the tax year you're applying. This means the company must be relatively new (typically in its first five years of generating revenue).

‍

Even if your startup is pre-revenue or hasn't turned a profit yet, you may still qualify.

‍

What Types of Businesses are Eligible?

If your company invests in innovation, you're likely eligible. Qualified industries include:

• SaaS startups developing new platforms, features, or backend systems
• Biotech firms conducting drug research or clinical testing
• Hardware startups prototyping devices or enhancing product performance
• Fintech companies building secure, scalable financial platforms
• AI and machine learning ventures training new models or experimenting with algorithms

‍

As long as your R&D work meets the IRS’s requirements (mainly that it involves technological experimentation and aims to improve a product or process), you’re on the right track.

‍

How Much Can You Claim?

As of 2023, qualified startups can claim up to $500,000 per year in R&D tax credits through the Payroll Tax Offset (this is an improvement from the previous $250,000 cap).

‍

This means that even if your startup isn’t profitable and owes no income tax, you can still receive a dollar-for-dollar credit to reduce your federal payroll tax liability.

‍

Specifically, the R&D Payroll Tax Offset can be applied to your employer portion of Social Security (6.2%) and, following updates in the Inflation Reduction Act, also your employer portion of Medicare taxes (1.45%).

‍

This credit offsets these payroll taxes when you file IRS Form 941 quarterly, thus helping your startup preserve much-needed cash.

‍

Here's a simple breakdown of how it works:

‍

Let’s say your early-stage SaaS company spends $300,000 on qualified R&D activities (e.g., software development, prototyping, testing). After calculating eligible expenses using IRS Form 6765, you determine you qualify for a $90,000 R&D tax credit.

‍

Even if your company had zero taxable income, you can elect to apply this $90,000 against your payroll taxes (thereby reducing or eliminating what you owe to the IRS for Social Security and Medicare contributions over the next few quarters).

‍

Now imagine a larger startup with extensive R&D operations. If they qualify for the full $500,000 cap, they can reduce their payroll tax burden across multiple quarters (thus allowing you to save capital to reinvest in hiring, product development, or scaling efforts).

‍

What Activities Qualify for the R&D Credit?

To claim the R&D Payroll Tax Offset, your startup must engage in activities that meet the IRS’s 4-Part Test.

‍

While “R&D” might sound like something only biotech labs do, many early-stage startups are surprised to learn they already qualify, especially those building new products or software or improving internal technologies.

‍

Here’s a breakdown of the four criteria:

‍

Qualified Purpose

The activity must focus on creating or improving a product, process, software, technique, formula, or invention. The improvement can be in functionality, performance, reliability, or quality.

‍

For instance, a startup that is building a mobile app and testing ways to improve its real-time syncing features could qualify because it’s improving functionality.

‍

Technological in Nature

The research must rely on hard sciences such as computer science, engineering, physics, or chemistry. This doesn’t mean you need a lab coat, just that your project is rooted in technical principles.

‍

For instance, a fintech company that is developing a secure payment integration using encryption protocols meets this criterion since it’s based on computer science.

‍

Elimination of Uncertainty

The activity must attempt to eliminate uncertainty related to capability, method, or final design. If you're unsure whether your idea will work (or how to make it work) and you try different approaches, it likely qualifies.

‍

For instance, a healthtech startup that isn’t sure which machine learning model will deliver accurate diagnostics. It tests several algorithms before choosing the best one. That’s an example of addressing technical uncertainty.

‍

Process of Experimentation

You must use a systematic process to evaluate alternatives. This includes modeling, testing, simulations, prototyping, or even trial and error (provided it’s documented).

‍

For instance, a SaaS startup that runs multiple A/B tests to determine which architecture scales better under load counts as experimentation.

‍

Step-by-Step Guide to Claiming the Payroll Tax Offset

Claiming the R&D Payroll Tax Offset may sound complex, but breaking it down into actionable steps makes it much more approachable. The steps below show how to claim the offset, from tracking qualified R&D expenses to filing the right IRS forms.

‍

Step 1: Track and document qualifying R&D expenses (QREs)

Start early; keep records for every dollar you want to claim. Qualified R&D expenses usually include:

• Wages for employees engaged in defining the technical uncertainty, supervising experiments, or building/testing prototypes
• Materials and supplies used in experimentation
• Contract research costs (generally capped at 65% when using outside vendors).

‍

To avoid IRS scrutiny, your documentation must be detailed and project-specific (such as timesheets tied to defined R&D tasks, lab notebooks, budgets, and formal experiment logs).

‍

The IRS Audit Techniques Guide requires records that support why each activity qualifies under § 41(d) and § 6001; reliance on estimates is discouraged unless contemporaneous documentation genuinely cannot be produced.

‍

Step 2: Complete IRS Form 6765

Form 6765 serves as the computation for your R&D tax credit and the document to make the payroll tax offset election.

‍

Use Schedule A (or B if easier) to compute your base credit via either the Regular Credit (~20%) or the Alternative Simplified Credit (~14% over the base amount). Fill in Section F (Qualified Research Expenses) and Section G (Business Components) to support your project-level calculations.

‍

The last page of the form is Section D, where you make the election and designate how much of your total R&D credit (up to $500,000 per tax year) you want to claim against payroll taxes rather than federal income taxes.

‍

Since this election cannot be made on an amended return, you must file Form 6765 timely (including extensions) for the tax year in question.

‍

Step 3: Elect the payroll tax offset on the form

In Section D (lines 41-44):

• Check the box declaring yourself a Qualified Small Business (QSB), i.e., under $5 million in gross receipts and no receipts before the last 5 consecutive years.
• Enter the part of your credit to apply against payroll taxes (up to $500K annually since 2023).
• If your entity has a general business credit carryforward, enter it (you can only elect payroll credit up to the lesser of your QRE-based credit, $500K per year, or your remaining credit carryforward).

‍

Your payroll tax offset election becomes irrevocable once filed, with Section 41(h) attaching strict IRS aggregation rules, especially for controlled groups.

‍

Step 4: File Form 8974 with your payroll tax return (Form 941)

Form 8974 translates your chosen credit amount into actual offsets against your quarterly Form 941 liabilities (Social Security and Medicare tax).

‍

Only begin using the payroll tax offset in the first calendar quarter that begins after you file your income tax return with the payroll tax election; that is, your Form 6765 and business return.

‍

Form 8974 first applies your credit to the employer portion of Social Security tax (up to $250K), then to the employer’s Medicare tax, and carries forward any unused portion from quarter to quarter.

‍

Attach 8974 to your first Form 941 and use it in each successive quarterly Form 941 until fully exhausted. This ensures up to $500K in annual credit is usable regardless of company profitability, as long as your payroll is subject to employer-side Social Security and Medicare tax.

‍

Step 5: Work with a tax advisor or R&D tax credit specialist

Professional help is recommended due to the strict IRS documentation requirements under § 41 and detailed audit guidance (including fixed base percentage rules, controlled group aggregation, and permissible exclusions).

‍

A seasoned R&D tax specialist can assist you with:

• Mapping project-level documentation to legal § 41 tests
• Choosing the most advantageous election between the traditional credit and payroll option
• Ensuring Form 6765 and Form 8974 are completed correctly and filed timely
• Defending your claim in case of an IRS examination, by preparing Strong substantiation and sensitivity reviews

‍

Here’s a checklist of the steps:

‍

How to Maximize Your Credit

Use R&D credit software or expert consultants

Automating the R&D tax credit process lets startups capture every dollar in eligible wage, supply, and contract expenses with forensic time capture, auto-coded activity logs, and instant audit support.

‍

Modern tools also integrate Form 6765 and Form 8974 submissions with your payroll provider. For most unprofitable startups, this approach yields a faster ROI than hiring a tax accountant after the fact.

‍

When paired with a qualified R&D credit specialist or CPA, you gain custom guidance on safe assumptions under the IRS’s four-part test and deeper scrutiny shielding in case of audit.

‍

Combine with Other Tax Credits (e.g., ERC / ERTC)

It’s possible to claim the R&D payroll tax offset and pandemic-era relief credits, but wage “double dipping” is not allowed.

‍

Wages used for the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC/ERC) cannot also count as R&D wages. Approved guidance clarifies that any such wages must be allocated first to whichever credit produces the highest benefit, then the rest may flow into the R&D credit pool.

‍

You may also look into Work Opportunity Tax Credits or orphan drug credits, but only if your documentation cleanly segregates eligible wages and costs among separate credit buckets.

‍

Plan R&D Spending

Since the payroll offset is elected annually on Form 6765 and applied beginning the first quarter after filing & election, scheduling substantial qualifying R&D early in the year can accelerate cash refunds mid-year.

‍

Similarly, if you’re approaching the $500K cap, front-loading activities across Q1/Q2 helps optimize return timing.

‍

With R&D costs now amortized over five years (15 for foreign research), carefully tracking monthly wage and supply outlays (and tying them back to your business roadmap) ensures maximum credit capture, especially under the Alternative Simplified Credit.

‍

How Chore Helps You Maximize the R&D Payroll Tax Offset

Even if your startup is unprofitable right now, you can still claim up to $500K per year with the R&D payroll tax offset as long as your back office is tuned properly.

‍

That’s where Chore comes in.

‍

Automated bookkeeping and payroll tagging

Chore syncs with providers like Gusto, Rippling, and QuickBooks to capture employee wages, contractor time, and supply spend tagged to R&D projects. These are important for your four-part IRS eligibility test.

‍

Accrual basis financials and reporting

With books closed by the 15th, real-time burn rate tracking, KPI dashboards, and project-level codes, Chore ensures accuracy for Form 6765 and payroll offset election on Form 8974.

‍

Fractional ops support with compliance built in

Your finance team is in-app, via Slack or phone, handling documentation, quarterly compliance, and audit preparedness so you can stay within the Qualified Small Business rules under the PATH Act and IRA.

‍

If you’re building something new and have spent time on engineering, prototyping, or regression testing, Chore can help turn those hours into real cash. Book a free consultation today to see how Chore can set up your startup for refundability.

‍

FAQs

Can startups that aren’t profitable still claim the R&D tax credit?

Yes. Even if your startup isn’t profitable and doesn’t owe income taxes, you can still benefit from the R&D tax credit by using it to offset up to $500,000 of your payroll tax liability annually through the Payroll Tax Offset.

‍

What expenses qualify for the R&D tax credit?

Qualified expenses include:

• Wages paid to employees involved in R&D
• Supplies used in R&D processes
• Contractor payments for U.S.-based R&D work
• Cloud computing or software used in development

‍

What if my startup doesn’t have any payroll yet?

You must have payroll tax liability (i.e., you pay employees and file Form 941) to benefit from the payroll tax offset. If you don’t yet have payroll, you can still accrue the credit and use it later when payroll tax liability arises.

‍

Should I work with an R&D tax credit specialist?

Yes, you should work with an R&D tax credit specialist, especially if you're a startup or new to the process. They can help:

• Maximize your credit by identifying all qualifying expenses
• Ensure IRS compliance and avoid errors
• Handle complex forms like 6765 and 8974
• Save your team time and reduce internal workload
• Offer low-risk pricing, often only charging if you receive the credit

‍

Can I still claim the R&D tax credit if I use a PEO or payroll provider?

Yes, you can still claim the R&D tax credit even if you use a PEO (Professional Employer Organization) or payroll provider, but there are a few things to know:

• Your startup still qualifies for the R&D Payroll Tax Offset as long as you meet the IRS criteria (i.e., you're a Qualified Small Business with less than $5M in gross receipts and within your first five years of revenue).
• You must still file Form 6765 with your federal income tax return to elect the payroll offset.
• Your PEO or payroll provider must then apply the offset by submitting Form 8974 along with their aggregate Form 941 on your behalf.

‍