Imagine you're the founder of a growing tech startup and you want to attract top talent without relinquishing equity. Traditional startup equity compensation methods like stock options might not align with your vision of maintaining full ownership.

‍

In this case, you can use phantom equity to offer your employees financial incentives that are tied to company performance without actual stock issuance.

‍

Phantom equity mirrors the value of real stock by providing cash bonuses equivalent to stock price appreciation over time. This approach allows employees to share in the company's success without diluting ownership or conferring voting rights.

‍

In this article, we will discuss what phantom equity is, how it works, and how to maximize its benefits.

‍

What is Phantom Equity?

Phantom equity is a startup equity compensation that mimics the benefits of stock ownership without actually giving employees real shares in the company.

‍

It’s a contractual agreement that grants employees the right to receive a cash payout or equivalent value based on the future valuation or sale price of the company’s stock.

‍

Unlike traditional equity, phantom equity doesn’t involve issuing real shares or diluting existing ownership. Instead, it works like a financial promise that reflects hypothetical ownership value.

‍

When a certain event occurs (such as a company sale, IPO, or defined milestone), employees with phantom equity receive a payout as if they had owned shares, even though no shares were ever transferred.

‍

Phantom equity is commonly used in:

• Startups and early-stage companies that want to offer equity for employees without diluting ownership
• Private firms that aren’t publicly traded and want to keep control of their shareholder structure
• Companies looking to reward executives and key talent with long-term incentives tied to company performance

‍

In a nutshell, phantom equity offers a flexible and tax-efficient way to align employees' interests with business growth. This makes it an important tool in modern phantom stock plans and synthetic equity strategies.

‍

How Does Phantom Equity Work?

How does phantom equity work? And what should companies and employees know about its structure, payout triggers, and tax implications?

‍

Structure of a Phantom Equity Agreement

A phantom stock plan is a contract between an employer and an employee that outlines the terms of the phantom equity grant. Unlike traditional stock options, phantom equity doesn’t involve actual stock but offers synthetic equity that mimics the benefits of stock ownership.

‍

The agreement usually specifies the number of phantom shares granted, the vesting schedule, and the valuation formula used to determine the payout. The company may also set conditions for payout events, such as a liquidity event (e.g., an acquisition) or the employee’s retirement.

‍

Vesting Schedules and Performance Conditions

Similar to stock options, phantom equity comes with a vesting schedule, which means employees will earn their phantom shares over time, based on either their length of service or meeting specific performance goals.

‍

For example, the vesting schedule may stipulate that employees earn 25% of their phantom equity each year for four years.

‍

Performance conditions might also be attached to phantom equity. These conditions could include individual or company-wide targets, such as revenue milestones or profitability goals.

‍

As employees achieve these milestones, they unlock additional phantom stock, making it an attractive incentive for those who help drive the company’s success.

‍

Payout Triggers

Phantom stock plans offer employees the benefits of equity without the challenges of actual stock ownership. However, the payout isn't automatic. Phantom equity payouts occur when certain trigger events happen:

• Liquidity Events: If the company is sold, goes public, or undergoes another type of exit, employees with phantom equity will receive a payout based on the company's valuation at that time.
• Retirement: If an employee retires and their phantom stock is vested, they may receive a payout based on the agreement's terms, typically based on the current value of the company.
• Termination: If the employee leaves voluntarily, they may forfeit unvested shares. However, in some cases of termination without cause, they may be entitled to some or all of their vested phantom equity.

‍

Tax Implications for the Company and Employee

Phantom equity has unique tax implications for the company and the employee. For the company, phantom stock plans are usually tax-deductible as a compensation expense when the payout is made, just like regular salaries or bonuses.

‍

However, the company should be prepared for cash-flow obligations when it’s time to make a payout.

‍

For employees, phantom equity is taxed as ordinary income when they receive the payout, unlike stock options, which may be eligible for capital gains tax treatment. This means employees may face a higher tax rate on their phantom equity gains, depending on the timing and size of the payout.

‍

Phantom Equity Example

To illustrate how phantom equity works, consider the following hypothetical example:

‍

An executive director is granted 1,000 phantom shares under a retention and performance incentive plan when the company's stock price is $50. After a vesting period of three years, the company's stock price has risen to $75. If the company’s phantom share plan is full value, the employee would receive a payout of $75,000.

‍

This was gotten using the formula below:

‍

Payout = Number of Phantom Shares X Stock Price at Payout

‍

Hence, Payout = 1,000 X $75 = $75,000

‍

Calculation of Potential Benefits

The potential benefits of phantom equity depend on the plan's structure:

‍

Full Value Phantom Stock Plans

These plans provide a payout based on the entire value of the company's stock at the time of a liquidity event or predetermined date.

‍

For example, if an employee holds 50,000 phantom shares and the company is sold for $1 million, each share is valued at $1, resulting in a $50,000 payout for the employee.

‍

Appreciation-Only Phantom Stock Plans

These plans offer payouts based solely on the appreciation in the company's stock value from the grant date to the payout date.

‍

For instance, if an employee is granted 50,000 phantom shares when the stock is valued at $1, and upon sale, the stock is valued at $2, the employee would receive a $50,000 payout, reflecting the $1 appreciation per share.

‍

Phantom Equity vs Stock Options

Phantom equity is an alternative to traditional stock options; it offers employees a stake in a company's success without actual stock ownership. The table below highlights the differences between these two forms of equity compensation:

‍

Advantages and Disadvantages of Phantom Equity

It's important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of phantom equity to know if it’s suitable for your organization.

‍

Advantages

No Dilution of Company Ownership

Implementing phantom equity ensures existing shareholders' ownership percentages remain unaffected, as no actual shares are issued. This feature is beneficial for companies that want to incentivize employees without altering the current equity distribution.

‍

Flexibility in Structuring Plans

Phantom equity plans offer customization to meet specific company objectives. Employers can design vesting schedules, performance metrics, and payout conditions that align with organizational goals.

‍

Attractive Incentive for Employees

These plans provide employees with financial rewards tied to the company's performance, fostering motivation and a sense of ownership. Employees benefit from the company's growth without personal investment, making it an appealing component of startup equity compensation.

‍

Simplicity from a Legal and Administrative Standpoint

Phantom equity plans are generally straightforward to administer. They do not require changes to the company's capitalization table or issuance of actual shares, simplifying legal processes and reducing administrative burdens.

‍

Encourages Long-Term Commitment

By tying benefits to the company's long-term performance, phantom equity plans encourage employees to remain with the company and contribute to its sustained success, aligning with retention strategies.

‍

Disadvantages

No Voting Rights or Dividends

Employees participating in phantom equity plans do not receive voting rights or dividends associated with actual stock ownership. This absence may impact employee engagement for those valuing shareholder privileges.

‍

May Not Be as Enticing as Real Equity

While phantom equity offers financial benefits, it lacks the tangible ownership experience of real equity. Some employees may perceive it as less valuable, potentially affecting its effectiveness as an incentive.

‍

Requires Careful Tax Planning

Payouts from phantom equity plans are taxed as ordinary income, which may be subject to higher tax rates than capital gains. Employers and employees should engage in thorough tax planning to manage these implications effectively.

‍

Cash-Based Obligation May Strain Company Finances During Payout Events

Since phantom equity payouts are often settled in cash, companies must ensure sufficient liquidity to meet these obligations. Large payouts can strain financial resources, especially during exit events or other triggering occurrences.

‍

How to Maximize the Benefits of Phantom Stock Plans

Implement the following strategies to maximize the potential of phantom stock plans:

‍

Customizing Vesting Schedules to Align with Company Goals

Design vesting schedules that promote long-term commitment and align with your startup's strategic objectives.

• Tie vesting to specific company achievements or individual performance metrics to ensure employees' rewards are directly linked to their contributions.
• Introduce a cliff period at the beginning of the vesting schedule to encourage retention, ensuring employees remain with the company for a minimum period before earning any benefits.
• Spread the vesting period over several years to maintain ongoing motivation and reduce turnover.

‍

Clear Communication with Employees About Plan Mechanics and Benefits

Ensure employees fully understand the phantom stock plan's structure and advantages.

• Organize sessions to explain how the plan works, including how payouts are calculated and the conditions for vesting.
• Provide clear, written materials outlining the plan's terms, potential benefits, and any associated risks.
• Keep employees informed about company performance and how it impacts the value of their phantom shares.

‍

Combine with Other Incentives (Bonuses, Real Equity, Profit-Sharing)

Integrate phantom stock plans with other compensation elements to create a comprehensive and attractive package.

• Offer cash bonuses linked to individual or company-wide performance metrics to complement phantom stock benefits.
• Provide options for employees to purchase actual company stock at favorable rates, giving them a tangible ownership stake.
• Implement profit-sharing schemes that distribute a portion of company profits to employees, enhancing their financial connection to company success.

‍

Work with Professionals to Avoid Pitfalls

Work with a legal professional to overcome the challenges of legal and tax regulations and to ensure the plan's effectiveness.

• Consult attorneys specializing in employee compensation to draft plan documents that comply with current laws and regulations.
• Collaborate with tax professionals to understand the tax implications for the company and employees, ensuring the plan is structured efficiently.
• Periodically assess the plan's adherence to evolving legal standards and make necessary adjustments.

‍

Set Realistic Valuation Metrics for Accurate and Fair Payouts

Establish valuation methods that reflect the company's worth and ensure fair compensation.

• Use recognized valuation techniques, such as discounted cash flow analysis or market comparisons, to determine share value.
• Update valuations annually or after significant company events to maintain accuracy.
• Align valuation metrics with key business milestones, such as revenue targets or product launches, to motivate performance.

‍

Wrapping Up

As discussed in this guide, phantom equity is valuable for companies that want to motivate and retain important employees by offering financial benefits linked to the company's performance without issuing stocks.

‍

This approach aligns employees' interests with those of shareholders, thereby encouraging a shared commitment to the organization's success. In addition, phantom equity plans help avoid ownership dilution, thereby preserving control for existing shareholders.

‍

However, these plans do not grant voting rights or dividends associated with actual stock ownership. When considering phantom equity, carefully assess your ability to manage potential cash flow implications, especially during payout events, and address the tax complexities that may arise for the organization and its employees.

‍

Thoughtfully considering these factors can help you determine if phantom equity aligns with your compensation strategies and long-term objectives.

‍

FAQs

What is the difference between real equity and phantom equity?

Here are the differences between real equity and phantom equity

• Real equity shareholders possess legal ownership, granting them voting rights and a say in corporate governance. Phantom equity holders, however, have no voting rights or influence over company decisions.
• Shareholders with real equity may receive dividends as a distribution of the company's profits. Phantom equity plans do not offer dividends, although some may provide cash payouts based on the company's performance.
• Real equity may qualify for favorable tax treatment, such as capital gains rates upon selling shares. In contrast, payouts from phantom equity are generally taxed as ordinary income, which can result in a higher tax liability.
• Issuing additional real equity can dilute the ownership percentage of existing shareholders. Phantom equity avoids this issue, as it does not involve issuing actual shares, thus preserving existing ownership structures.

‍

What is the difference between phantom equity and profits interest?

The differences between phantom equity and profits interest include the following:

• Phantom equity holders do not possess legal ownership or voting rights, whereas profits interest holders are actual partners with associated rights.
• Phantom equity payouts are taxed as ordinary income. In contrast, profits interests, if structured correctly, can be taxed at capital gains rates upon a qualifying sale, offering potential tax advantages.
• Phantom equity is often used in corporate entities, while profits interests are specific to partnerships like LLCs.
• Phantom equity plans may be simpler to administer as they help avoid the challenges associated with partnership interests, such as issuing K-1 forms. However, profit interests provide genuine equity participation, which can be more motivating for employees seeking ownership.

‍

What is another name for phantom equity?

Phantom equity is also known as phantom stock, shadow stock, phantom shares, virtual stock, and virtual shares. The specific terminology depends on the company's structure and the details of the plan.

‍

What determines the value of phantom equity units?

The value of phantom equity units is tied to the company's stock price or valuation. This ensures the value of the phantom units fluctuates in alignment with the company's performance, thereby providing employees with incentives that mirror actual stock ownership.

‍